2012 · Devices & clinical
Clip occlusion versus coil embolization for the treatment of cerebral aneurysms
Rahal JP, Malek AM.
J Neurosurg Sci 56(3):175-90, 2012.
PMID 22854586
In plain language
Brain aneurysms, weak bulging spots on blood vessels, can be treated with open surgery to place a small clip across them, or from inside the vessel by filling them with tiny platinum coils. The fact that an aneurysm can be treated one way does not mean that way is the best choice.
This review discusses how to choose between the two. It weighs the aneurysm's shape and location, how easy it is to reach, long-term results on imaging, and the patient's age, other illnesses and preferences about hospital stay, recovery and follow-up scans. Newer options such as balloon or stent support for coils and flow-diverting stents are balanced against the lower cost and simpler follow-up after clipping.
The authors stress balancing technical skill with safety so that each method's advantages are not lost to its drawbacks.
A plain-language summary for patients and families. It is not medical advice, and individual results vary.
Abstract
Advances in the endovascular treatment of intracranial aneurysms since the advent of detachable coil embolization continue to expand the spectrum of lesions amenable to minimally invasive therapy. The feasibility of treating a given cerebral aneurysm by a given open or endovascular modality does not necessarily make such an approach the optimal choice. Rather, any given cerebral aneurysm and patient should be carefully analyzed on a multitude of parameters which are based on available adjunctive technology, aneurysm morphology and characteristics, endovascular vs. microsurgical accessibility, and long-term angiographic outcome. In addition to patient age, co-morbid conditions, lesion size and attendant risk, one must also consider patient preference with respect to length of hospital stay, recovery duration and required follow-up and radiographic assessments. The relentless improvements in minimally invasive embolization therapies ranging from coiling with adjunctive balloon and stent support to the emerging role of flow-diversion must be balanced against the lower cost and complexity associated with longitudinal clinical and radiographic follow-up requirements of microsurgical clipping. This review will consider the various factors involved in the determination of optimal modality choice based on an assessment of clinical, morphological and anatomical considerations. In this rapidly evolving field, the quest for maximizing protection from aneurysm rupture at the lowest neurological cost dictates that a balance be maintained between technical virtuosity and procedural safety of either microsurgical clipping or endovascular repair to insure that the advantages of the selected modality not be negated by its associated shortcomings.
Abstract as indexed in PubMed (PMID 22854586). Copyright the publisher.
Cite this paper
Rahal JP, Malek AM. Clip occlusion versus coil embolization for the treatment of cerebral aneurysms. J Neurosurg Sci 56(3):175-90. 2012. PMID: 22854586.